Brannoc Hale looked at Adrian's face for a long time in the grey dawn light on the platform, and did not say I told you so.
He did not say anything at all. He put down the silver flask, and got up out of his chair, and walked over, and took Adrian's chin in his one big hand, and turned his face to the left, and to the right, and pressed his thumb, not gently, against the swollen purple ridge of bone under Adrian's eye. He lifted Adrian's shirt and looked at Nessa's bandage, and grunted.
"Who bound that?"
"The smith's daughter."
"Good job. Better than I'd have done." He let the shirt drop. "Oak?"
"Lead core."
"How many?"
"Nine."
"How many times did you get up?"
"Nine."
Brannoc was quiet. The marsh mist moved around the stilts of the shack. Out on the water a heron lifted and flew.
"And how many," the old Hunter said, very quietly, "did you give back?"
"None."
"Couldn't? Or didn't?"
Adrian looked at him.
"Won't," he said.
Brannoc Hale looked down at him for a long moment with his pale bloodshot eyes. Then he let go of Adrian's chin and went back to his chair and sat down in it and picked up the flask and did not drink from it.
"Who was it?" he said.
"A candidate. A baron's son. Lucan Ardent."
The flask stopped halfway to Brannoc's mouth.
It was a very small thing. Adrian would not have seen it at all, a year ago. But he had spent a winter watching Brannoc Hale - the way he moved, the way he sat, the way his hand went to the flask - and he saw it. The old Hunter's whole body went still, the way a heron's goes still before it strikes, and his thumb moved on the silver flask, once, across the worn engraving.
Wren.
"Ardent," said Brannoc.
"His father's the Baron of the Eastmarch."
"I know who his father is." Brannoc put the flask down on the planks, very carefully, as if it might break. He did not look at Adrian. He looked at the marsh. "Stay away from that family, farm boy. All of them. The father and the son and the whole rotten tree." His voice was very low. "That's not a rule. That's advice. The only advice I'll ever give you for free."
"Why?"
"No Temple talk," said Brannoc Hale. "Rule Two." He picked the flask back up and drank, a long swallow, and wiped his beard. "Post. Go on. You can stand on it with a cracked rib. I've done it with two."
Adrian stood on the post. He did not fall in.
But all morning, as the mist came and went, he watched Brannoc Hale in his chair on the platform, sitting with the silver flask in his hand, turning it, and turning it, and turning it, and not drinking from it at all.
❖ ❖ ❖
The Thaw Fair began the next day, and on the first morning of the Thaw Fair, in the great hall of the Guildhall of Profession, two hundred and forty candidates sat the written test.
Adrian had not known there would be a written test. Nobody had told him. Clerk Wosk had said the Proving, and Adrian had imagined the yard, and the sand, and the sword. He had not imagined the long tables of the great hall cleared of their ledgers and lined with benches, and a slate and a stick of chalk and a sheet of rough paper and a stub of pencil laid out on the table in front of every place, and two hundred and forty candidates filing in and sitting down, and a very tall grey-bearded man in a black Guild gown with a silver chain of office walking up and down the aisles with his hands behind his back.
"Guild Master Examiner Rusk," whispered Pell, sliding onto the bench beside Adrian. "He's the one who marks. He hates everybody too. He and Wosk play chess on Sundays. They've been playing the same game for eleven years."
"What are you doing here?"
"Sitting the written test," said Pell. "Obviously. What does it look like?"
Adrian stared at him.
"You're a candidate?"
"Of course I'm a candidate. Look." Pell pulled a cord out of the collar of his red velvet coat. On it hung an iron candidate's badge, stamped with a square tower on one side and, on the other, the number 212. "Scout," said Pell. "I'm a very good scout. I can get in anywhere. And out again, which is the important part."
"Why?"
Pell's clever face flickered.
"Because," he said, very lightly, "when a man owes money to a Veyrholt moneylender called Grisel Crook, and can't pay it, and then drinks himself into the river off the Bridge of Bells, the moneylender goes looking for what else he left behind. And the Crown's law says a debtor's child may be bound over in service until the debt is paid." He tucked the badge back into his collar. "Unless that child is a Guild candidate, under the protection of the Crown." He smiled his very good smile. "So I'm a Scout."
Adrian did not say anything. There was nothing to say.
"Anyway, it doesn't matter," said Pell, "because I'm going to pass. I'm very good at tests." He lowered his voice. "Especially this one. It's the same every year. I've got the answers."
"You've got the answers?"
"Well. Not all of them. The essay's different every year. But the law part and the sums part, I've got in here." He tapped his velvet cuff. "Wosk's apprentice drinks at the Crooked Eel. He talks when he drinks. I'll share, if you like. Seeing as you took nine for me."
"No," said Adrian.
Pell looked at him. "No?"
"No."
"You're Null. You're a farm boy. Farm boys can't read. Half the candidates in this hall can't read. They'll fail the whole first part and they won't even be allowed in the yard." Pell's green eyes were very bright. "Adrian. I'm serious. Take the cuff."
"I can read," said Adrian.
Pell stared at him. Then, very slowly, he remembered a delivery list on the back of a smithy order slip, written in perfect common Temple script by the light of a forge.
"Oh," said Pell. "Right. The strangest turnip."
❖ ❖ ❖
At the far end of the hall, on a low platform, two chairs had been set for observers.
In one of them sat Clerk Wosk, with his ink-stained hands folded on his black gown and his face like thunder.
In the other, in a plain brown habit, with his hands empty in his lap, sat Brother Odo.
Adrian saw him as soon as he sat down, and his whole body went cold. The grey window, which had been dark all morning - it was always dark in the city now - did not so much as flicker.
But Brother Odo had nothing in his hands. No velvet case. No brass rod. No acorn cup. He sat very straight in his chair with his soft young face turned toward the long tables, and his head tilted just slightly to one side, and his hands were empty.
"The Temple sends an observer every year," whispered Pell, following his gaze. "To make sure nobody cheats on the Traits part. Like claiming a Trait they haven't got." He snorted. "But they can't bring anything in. Guild Charter. Article Two. No instrument of the Temple may be carried within the walls of the Guildhall." He grinned. "The Guild wrote that one after they found a Temple listening-horn under the Master's desk. Two hundred years ago. Wosk told me. He's still angry about it."
Adrian looked at Brother Odo's empty hands.
Then he looked at the way Brother Odo's head was tilted.
Article Two did not say anything about ears.
❖ ❖ ❖
"Candidates." Guild Master Examiner Rusk's voice filled the great hall without seeming to try. "You will turn over the paper in front of you when the bell rings. You will have until the Temple bells on the hill ring the fourth hour. There are four parts. Reading. Law. Reckoning. And the essay." He stopped at the end of the hall and looked down the long tables with a pair of cold grey eyes. "Any candidate who speaks, or looks at another candidate's paper, or has anything written on his hands, his sleeves, his cuffs, or any other part of his person, will be struck from the roll and thrown into the river. I am not joking about the river. Ask Clerk Wosk."
Clerk Wosk nodded grimly.
Beside Adrian, Pell Ashworth very quietly began to tuck his velvet cuffs up inside his sleeves.
A bell rang.
Adrian turned over his paper.
❖ ❖ ❖
The first part was a passage in common Temple script, and a list of questions about it.
It was about the founding of the Guilds. It was long, and dull, and full of long words - charter, Profession, apprenticeship, sovereign, dominion - and Adrian read it slowly, the way Crane had taught him to read, sounding out the hardest words in his head, his finger moving along the lines. It was not hard. It was only long. And all around him, up and down the long tables, he could hear candidates breathing too fast, and pencils not moving, and somewhere behind him, very quietly, a boy crying.
He answered all six questions. It took him most of an hour.
He thought, as he wrote the last answer, of a man with a soft voice and a long clever face, sitting across from him at a little table under a round window, saying You're doing very well with common script, Adrian. Better than any student I've had in some years.
He did not know how he felt about that. He put it away.
❖ ❖ ❖
The second part was law.
It was written in the King's script, which was older and squarer and harder, and which Adrian could only half read. His mother had read it with him by candlelight, eleven lines of it, over and over, until he knew them by heart. He had not read anything else in the King's script since.
He looked at the first question. It was about the rights of a journeyman to leave his master. He did not know. He did not know the second question either, about the Guild's share of a Profession-holder's earnings. He guessed. He did not know the third.
The fourth question said: State, as fully as you are able, the protections afforded by the Crown to a candidate of a Guild of Profession, and the conditions of those protections.
Adrian sat and looked at it.
Then he picked up his pencil, and wrote, in the King's script, very carefully, from memory, eleven lines.
Of Candidates to the Guilds of Profession, and their Protection in Transit.
Any subject of the Crown, being twelve years of age or more, may declare himself a candidate to a Guild of Profession, before any sworn witness of the Crown's law, being a magistrate, a lord of the land, or an ordained priest of a parish-
He wrote all of it. Every word. Every letter that did not exist anymore. Laws of the Crown of Calvane, Volume the Third. Proof shown. Thirty days. And when he had written all eleven lines, he put down his pencil, and looked up, and found that Guild Master Examiner Rusk had stopped in the aisle beside him, and was reading it over his shoulder.
The tall grey-bearded man did not say anything. He read it through to the end. Then he looked down at Adrian's face - at the black eye, and the split lip, and the Null farm boy's badge with the number one on it - with an expression that Adrian could not read at all.
Then he walked on.
❖ ❖ ❖
The third part was reckoning, and Adrian nearly laughed out loud.
If a Hunter sells four brace of duck at seven copper the brace, and pays the Guild one part in ten-
If a smith has twelve dozen blanks to deliver, and has delivered eight dozen and five-
If a debt of thirty silver bears interest at one part in twelve each quarter, what will be owed after-
He had been doing sums like these in the dark in his head since he was ten years old. Lying in the loft, listening to his father through the wall. Counting coins in a clay jar that nobody thought he knew about. He did them all without using the slate once.
Beside him, Pell had gone very pale. Pell's cuffs were tucked up inside his sleeves, where he could not get at them, and the Guild Master Examiner had been walking up and down their row, back and forth, back and forth, for twenty minutes.
And then Adrian saw Pell's eyes lift, very slightly, and fix on something across the table.
Lucan Ardent was sitting opposite them.
Adrian had not noticed him come in. He had come in late, with a Guild usher, and taken the last place on the bench across the long table, and bent his fair head over his paper, and had not once looked up. He was writing very fast, in a fine elegant hand. And at the collar of his grey linen tunic, catching the light from the high windows, was his small gold pin in the shape of a rising sun.
It was a very bright, very polished pin. It was almost like a little mirror.
And from where Pell was sitting, at exactly the right angle, if you looked at it very, very carefully, and if you had very good eyes, and if the person wearing it was writing his answers to the reckoning in large clear figures down the right-hand side of his page-
Adrian looked at Pell.
Pell did not look at Adrian. Pell was copying down a column of figures, with his lips very slightly moving, and the most innocent face in Calvane.
Adrian looked back at his own paper.
He did not say anything. It was not his to say. But he did find, as he worked the last sum - a question about how much wool a wagon could carry - that he was having some difficulty keeping his split lip from smiling.
❖ ❖ ❖
The fourth part was the essay.
There was only one question. It was written at the top of a fresh sheet of paper in large, clear, common Temple script, so that every candidate could read it, even those who had failed the first three parts.
Describe your Trait, and how you will use it in the service of the Crown.
Adrian looked at it for a long time.
All around him, pencils were moving. Everybody had something to write. Everybody had a Trait. [Keen Nose], and I will use it to track for the Crown. [Sturdy Back], and I will carry for the Crown. [Radiant Oath], and I will lead the Crown's knights into battle - he could see Lucan Ardent, across the table, writing and writing without stopping, a whole page already.
Adrian did not have a Trait.
He had black bars.
He sat with his pencil over the page and thought about lying. It would be easy. Nobody would ever know. He could write [Keen Eyes], Common, and I will use it to track. Brother Odo was at the end of the hall. Brother Odo could hear a heart at twenty paces. Brother Odo would not hear a pencil.
He thought about Brannoc Hale's fifth rule.
Then he picked up his pencil and wrote.
I do not have a Trait. I am Null.
In my village, I watched my father cut hay. He has [Steady Arm], which makes his swing straight. But I saw that his knee catches, every twentieth swing, and the cut goes shallow at the end. [Steady Arm] did not show him that. He had cut hay for twenty years and did not know. I told him, and he moved his foot, and now it does not catch.
I think a Trait is a gift you are handed, and I have not been handed one. So I have to watch, and practice, and get things wrong, and get them right. It is very slow. But I think the Crown needs some people who have to learn things slowly. Because people who learn things slowly see where the knee catches.
That is how I will serve the Crown.
He read it through once. It was very short. Everybody else had written a page. Lucan Ardent was on his second.
He put down his pencil anyway.
❖ ❖ ❖
The Temple bells on the hill rang the fourth hour.
Guild Master Examiner Rusk collected the papers himself, walking down the long tables, taking each one and glancing at it and adding it to a stack under his arm. When he got to Adrian's, he glanced at it. And stopped. And read the essay. Standing in the aisle, with two hundred and forty candidates waiting, he read all of it, which did not take long.
He did not say anything. He put it on the stack and walked on.
"Results at the sixth hour," the Guild Master Examiner announced from the end of the hall. "On the board in the yard. The pass mark is sixty in a hundred. Any candidate below it will not sit the second part of the Proving, and may reapply in autumn." He looked at the tables with his cold grey eyes. "Get out."
❖ ❖ ❖
The results went up on the great board in the Guildhall yard at the sixth hour, in Clerk Wosk's large clear hand, in order of roll number.
A crowd of candidates stood in front of it in the slush, pushing and craning. Adrian did not push. He was number one. He was at the top.
- Vale, A. - Hunter - Null. Reading 22/25. Law 9/25. Reckoning 25/25. Essay 2/25. TOTAL 58.
Fifty-eight.
Adrian stood in the cold yard and looked at the number and felt the ground go out from under him, the way Brannoc's post went out from under him, and there was no marsh to fall into, and nothing to roll through. Just a number. Two short.
Essay: two.
"Oh, no," said Pell, beside him, very quietly. "Oh, Adrian. No."
And then Adrian saw the line below it. It had been added in a different hand. Not Wosk's large clear letters. A thin, sharp, slanting hand, in red ink, squeezed in underneath.
Discretionary merit, by order of the Master Examiner: +4. For the knee. TOTAL 62. PASS.
Adrian read it three times.
"For the knee," said Pell. "What knee? What does that mean? Whose knee?"
Adrian did not answer. He could not.
Further down the board, among the two hundreds, Pell's line said: 212. Ashworth, P. - Scout - [Silver Tongue]. Reading 19/25. Law 21/25. Reckoning 25/25. Essay 11/25. TOTAL 76. PASS. And next to Reckoning, in the same thin red slanting hand, very small, someone had written: Remarkable. Identical to Ardent's, including the error in question nine.
Pell read that line, and went the color of his coat.
And near the bottom of the board, the name that everyone in the yard was looking at:
Ardent, L. - Swordsman - [Radiant Oath] (Heroic). Reading 25/25. Law 24/25. Reckoning 24/25. Essay 25/25. TOTAL 98. PASS. First of the roll.
❖ ❖ ❖
Adrian turned away from the board.
And saw, in the stone gallery on the far side of the yard, in the thin grey spring sunlight, two people sitting side by side on a bench, watching the crowd of candidates.
One of them was a middle-aged woman in the dark blue robe and square black cap of a Crown magistrate, with a gold chain of office across her chest and a pair of spectacles on her nose.
The other was a short, solid woman in a long black coat, with a white scar running from her left temple to the corner of her jaw.
Inquisitor Maelis Dorne was not looking at the board. She was not looking at the crowd. She was looking directly across the yard at Adrian Vale, and she did not look away when he saw her.
She leaned over and said something to the magistrate. The magistrate looked at Adrian too, over her spectacles, for a long, thoughtful moment.
Then the Inquisitor raised one hand, very slightly, from her knee. Not a wave. More like a gatepost acknowledging that the gate has swung.
And she mouthed, across forty yards of slush and noise and candidates, two words that Adrian did not need to hear to understand.
With proof.